Everything is Barter

December 18th, 2017
taxes
If you drive me to the airport and I give you money, that's taxable. Or if we agree that I'll babysit your kids in exchange for the ride, that's taxable as well, being barter. [1] On the other hand, if you give me a ride to be helpful, and then later I watch your kids as a favor, I think that's not taxable. But I don't see how to draw the line here: instead of transacting in money or direct barter we're transacting in favors or social capital.

In some cases I think it may come down to whether we make an explicit agreement vs doing things informally. If I let a friend live with me because I have a spare room, and then they decide to spend weekends fixing up the house out of gratitude, I think that's not taxed. But if we explicitly agree that I will waive rent in exchange to 12hr/week of house repairs that probably is taxed. Penalizing people for being explicit in their interactions with each other seems harmful, though, as clarity in expectations can be a good way to reduce conflict.

Other things seem even messier. What if I take a job that pays less because I value the experience I'm gaining. What if it's for the fun? Prestige? Social impact? Or imagine I live in the US and want to donate to a charity that's tax-deductible in another country, and you vice-versa, so we each agree to donate to the other's charity. Or I agree to give up eating pigs in exchange to your giving up eating eggs. Is any of this taxable? Should it be?

Mostly I'm just pretty confused. I think it's possible that lots of things are technically taxable but most people don't report them and the IRS doesn't really expect them to be reported?

[1] Barter in the US is taxed as if we had each performed our services for "fair market value" in money. So if $50 would have been a fair price for the ride and for the babysitting, we each report an additional $50 of income.

Referenced in: Market Basket vs Peapod

Comment via: google plus, facebook, substack

Recent posts on blogs I like:

Paid Subscriber Questions Post

I have picked up a lot of new paid subscribers since the last time I did something like this, so: let's do a subscriber questions post!

via Thing of Things July 21, 2025

Retrospective on life tracking and effectiveness systems

I’ve been doing life tracking for around 10 years, and this post is looking back at some things I learned from the data (since my previous retrospective in 2017). Highlights include what I get out of the Oura ring, correlations between sleep and deep work…

via Victoria Krakovna July 4, 2025

Elixir's Last Dance

On May 18th, the contra dance band Elixir had their last gig ever. The dance was packed: there were three hundred people. It was the only dance BIDA has ever done where they sold tickets. People flew from across the country just to hear Elixir play one la…

via Lily Wise's Blog Posts June 5, 2025

more     (via openring)