Open-Hand Catan

December 9th, 2017
games

The rules of Settlers of Catan say "each player keeps their resource cards hidden" but in my experience the game is much more fun if resource cards are visible:

  • Much less time spent proposing trades. If I really want a brick and don't remember whether anyone has one, I might make several offers in turn ("one sheep ... two sheep ... three sheep ... three sheep and a wheat, come on!") needing to pause between each one to give people time to react. With open hands you're never proposing incompatible trades.

  • Much more fluid trading. Having open hands means other players can model each other better, and so are more likely to propose trades that others will find acceptable. I need a brick for a settlement, and I can see that if you had one more wheat you could build a city, so I offer a brick for a wheat.

  • More trading overall. The previous two points remove friction from trades, which means more trades happen. More trades means, effectively, richer players, which speeds the game up beyond just the time gained from not proposing incompatible or unacceptable trades.

I find open hands enough better that if I'm playing with a new group, even if I can't convince them all to play open hands people are usually ok with me having my hand visible. I find I end up doing more trades than other people because it's easier for people to trade with me, and trades help you a lot. There are disadvantages, like someone moving the robber has a better sense of what they could get if they played it on me, but I don't think it hurts me overall.

(I got into playing open-hand at Swarthmore where this was the standard way to play. Local legend had it that this was adopted to re-level the playing field after a student with a very good memory (hi Fred!) was able to mentally keep track of exactly what was in everyone's hands.)

Referenced in: Two-player Catan

Comment via: google plus, facebook, substack

Recent posts on blogs I like:

Tuberculosis Considered As Dating Strategy

Against some evopsych

via Thing of Things July 8, 2025

Retrospective on life tracking and effectiveness systems

I’ve been doing life tracking for around 10 years, and this post is looking back at some things I learned from the data (since my previous retrospective in 2017). Highlights include what I get out of the Oura ring, correlations between sleep and deep work…

via Victoria Krakovna July 4, 2025

Elixir's Last Dance

On May 18th, the contra dance band Elixir had their last gig ever. The dance was packed: there were three hundred people. It was the only dance BIDA has ever done where they sold tickets. People flew from across the country just to hear Elixir play one la…

via Lily Wise's Blog Posts June 5, 2025

more     (via openring)