A calming strategy

December 6th, 2017
kids
When Lily (3.5y) is very upset about something fixable, here's something I've found helpful:
L: Papa I don't want this cup! This cup is blue! I don't like this blue cup!
My first impulse is just to fix the thing:
J: That's ok Lily, here's an orange one.
If she's not very worked up then this will often work fine. She takes the orange cup and moves on with her life. But if she's pretty upset then I find this tends to continue like:
L: That's not what I wanted! I don't want that cup! That cup is too small! I want a cup like my blue cup but orange!
I think what's happening here is I haven't given her time to calm down. She gets the new cup, still feels sad and angry, and finds something else to be sad and angry about. And now she's gotten set on a kind of cup I don't have for her.

What I've found works better is moving slowly and being collaborative:

J: What would be better?
L: I want a different cup!
J: Let's go over and look at the cups and you can pick one out.
L: [chooses an orange cup]
This gives her feelings time to dissipate, so that by the time she has the new cup she's ready to enjoy life again. She's also the one making the decision, so I have buy-in from her and we're less likely to go in a direction that isn't fixing the underlying problem.
Referenced in:

Comment via: google plus, facebook, substack

Recent posts on blogs I like:

Exercises in benchmarking and evals, part 7: DeepSWE, Senior SWE-Bench, napkin math, and winter tires

This is part of a series of exercises on benchmarking, evals, and experimental design (1, 2, 3, 4, 5, 6)1. We're going to look at three questions, which are presented before the answers to give you time to think about the questions before seeing the a…

via Posts on July 23, 2026

Donation recommendations for effective altruists (July 2026)

My recommendation for donors who are American citizens or permanent residents is that they donate directly to high-value political candidates.

via Thing of Things July 22, 2026

Let's Taboo the V-Word

Read this post on Substack.

via Home July 12, 2026

more     (via openring)