• Posts
  • RSS
  • ◂◂RSS
  • Contact

  • Metacharities

    June 5th, 2012
    giving, metacharities  [html]
    It's clear that by giving to GiveWell's top charities you can do a lot of good. I wouldn't know about those charities, though, without GiveWell working to find them. Perhaps I could do more good by giving to GiveWell than to their top charities, by allowing them to put more research into identifying even better ones?

    GiveWell is an example of a "meta-charity", one that evaluates charities. There are also meta-charities that promote giving more and giving better, such as 80,000 Hours, Bolder Giving, and Giving What We Can. They could all use more money to hire more professional giving advocates. [1] If they can turn a dollar of donations into substantially more than a dollar of increased donations to effective charities, isn't that the best use of my money?

    GiveWell isn't currently limited by donations [2] and Bolder Giving doesn't emphasize giving effectively, so I'm really just looking at 80,000 Hours and Giving What We Can. How do I know whether a dollar spent on advocacy through one of them goes farther than a dollar given directly to the charities they advocate? What is the additional amount of donations they can move per dollar I give them?

    The simplest thing is to survey the people who you've influenced to find out how much they're giving to effective charities that they wouldn't be otherwise. Add to this a discounted estimate of what they will continue to give accounting for attrition. Divide by the money you've spent, converting volunteer time to money at whatever your full cost per employee would have been. [3] Is this good enough? What should I watch out for?

    One thing that does worry me about giving to them is that I might displace other donations. Let's say it turns out they can make a strong argument that they're moving 10x in additional donations for each dollar they get, but that you can only grow so fast and so they have much less room for more funding than the amount they could bring in. There may be people who will be moved by this 10x boost to give more than they would otherwise. I'm not one of them: I set aside money to donate and being confronted with a particularly effective giving oppertunity isn't going to get me to give more. So it's better if these flexible people do the metacharity supporting.


    [1] I do some as a part-time giving advocate, blogging, maintaining the Smart Giving subreddit, and hosting effective giving meetups, the next one of which is the evening of Friday July 6th.

    [2] When Julia wrote to them about a month ago they said they we're fine for the time being.

    Update 2014-12-22: As of December 2014 GiveWell now does think they could use additional funding effectively.

    [3] Giving What We Can tells me they've done this, and I'm trying to get data from them to see if I can trust their methodology.

    Comment via: google plus, facebook

    Recent posts on blogs I like:

    It's ok to feed stray cats

    Before we had kids, Jeff and I fostered a couple of cats. One had feline AIDS and was very skinny. Despite our frugal grocery budget of the time, I put olive oil on her food, determined to get her healthier. I knew that stray cats were not a top global pr…

    via Giving Gladly May 15, 2021

    Collections: Teaching Paradox, Europa Universalis IV, Part III: Europa Provincalis

    This is the third part of our series (I, II) examining the historical assumptions of Paradox Interactive’s grand strategy computer game set in the early modern period, Europa Universalis IV (which is in turn the start of a yet larger series looking at sev…

    via A Collection of Unmitigated Pedantry May 14, 2021

    Randal O’Toole Gets High-Speed Rail Wrong

    Now that there’s decent chance of US investment in rail, Randal O’Toole is resurrecting his takes from the early Obama era, warning that high-speed rail is a multi-trillion dollar money sink. It’s not a good analysis, and in particular it gets the reality…

    via Pedestrian Observations May 12, 2021

    more     (via openring)


  • Posts
  • RSS
  • ◂◂RSS
  • Contact