• Posts
  • RSS
  • ◂◂RSS
  • Contact

  • Hit frequencies

    December 2nd, 2016
    tech  [html]
    When load testing server-side software there are two straight-forward options:
    1. Stress all endpoints evenly
    2. Stress one endpoint in isolation
    For example, if you're testing a dynamic website with siege you could (1) give it a list of all the urls on your site and have it rotate among them, or you could (2) pick a representive url and just hit that one repeatedly. Like any synthetic test this isn't completely realistic, but in this case you're missing something pretty important: if you want to test something that uses caching, you need to approximate the distribution of a real workload.

    Why? How well caching works depends on your hit rate, which depends on what the distribution of your requests looks like. Situation (1) is a caching worst-case, (2) is a caching best case, and your real situation is somewhere in the middle. For example, from my access logs over the past couple years, here's the distribution of requests I've seen:

    1275358 /news.rss
    562369 /
    437312 /favicon.ico
    406583 /index
    168296 /robots.txt
    162728 /p/
    116353 /simple_piano_recordings/piano_chords.svg
    94048 /icdiff
    92680 /p/mercury-spill
    63728 /wsgi/json-comments-cached/gp/i6WrmjSHXLg
    [snip ~1k entries]
    1179 /news/2011-11-02
    1178 /wsgi/json-comments/gp/YTnbXQoRPRN
    1178 /fiddle-clip-on/pictures/11-top.jpg
    [snip ~10k entries]
    113 /news/back_from_564.rss
    113 /news/2012-07-24
    113 /news/2012-07-09.html
    [snip ~100k entries]
    3 /nextbus/omnitrans/82/7387/
    3 /nextbus/art/1135/759763/
    3 /nextbus/mbta/39/6460/
    [snip ~1M entries]
    1 /ngx_pagespeed_beacon?ets=load:906&rload=1605...
    1 /nextbus/jtafla/17/1433/next/
    1 /news/all/trillion-dollar-platinum-coin

    This is kind of a mess, but the main idea is that we have a few "hot" endpoints, and then a long tail of less popular entries. I can use this distribution in load testing, to get something between uniform sampling (option 1) and singleton sampling (option 2) that better represents what real load on the site would look like.

    In case this is useful to other people, here's the frequency list (hits-frequency.txt.gz) and a short script to sample from it (generate_urls.py).

    Comment via: google plus, facebook

    Recent posts on blogs I like:

    Collections: Bread, How Did they Make it? Part III: Actually Farming

    As the third part (I, II) of our look at the basic structure of food production in the pre-modern world (particularly farming grain to make bread) we’re going to finally look at how one actually farms grain to make bread. Now that we have all of our farme…

    via A Collection of Unmitigated Pedantry August 7, 2020

    The Limits of Regional Rail

    I recently found myself involved in a discussion about Boston regional rail that involved a proposal to do more thorough regional rail-subway integration. Normally, S-Bahn systems mix some aspects of longer-range regional rail and some aspects of urban me…

    via Pedestrian Observations August 5, 2020

    Tools for keeping focused

    no badges • close slack • check email 1x/day • keep todos visible • use rss • kindle + rss • hide phone apps • block ui elements • block sites • better window switcher • no tabs

    via benkuhn.net August 4, 2020

    more     (via openring)


  • Posts
  • RSS
  • ◂◂RSS
  • Contact