• Posts
  • RSS
  • ◂◂RSS
  • Contact

  • GiveWell and Money Moved

    January 13th, 2012
    ea  [html]
    Without thinking about it much, I had assumed GiveWell tracked 'money moved' primarily so they could tell how they were doing. The more money their top charities receive that is directly attributable to GiveWell, the more of an effect they're having. While it does fill this role, after talking to Holden [1] my understanding is that's it's actually more useful than this.

    Most reviews don't require substantial cooperation from the organization being reviewed. A restaurant reviewer shows up, ideally appearing just as any other customer, orders various things, and reports back on the experience. Consumer Reports buys a bunch of blenders, tests them against each other, and publishes a story on the best blenders. But charities are different: you need them to work with you to get the data you need to evaluate them. If you can say "in 2010 we moved over $1M to our top rated charity," they're going to be much more willing to do this work than if all you can say is "we're reviewing charities so people can see where they do best to donate." This is especially true when you intend to publish reviews that talk honestly about failings: charities are very cautious about admitting imperfection.

    This is also why they push so much for people to give through their website: it lets them track how much money they're moving. I know many people aren't so excited about tracking, but this is a case where I think it's really helpful.

    Update 2012-11-04: GiveWell just posted something similar.


    [1] After Julia posted on picking a cause, he wrote to her and asked if she would like to talk. The three of us talked for about 45min last night, and he mostly convinced me that giving to AMF or SCI was better than to Oxfam, IPA, or J-PAL.

    Comment via: google plus, facebook

    Recent posts on blogs I like:

    How to extend pockets

    Make women's pants pockets big enough to hold a phone properly The post How to extend pockets appeared first on Otherwise.

    via Otherwise May 19, 2022

    Buckingham Palace

    I love England. Especially because of the big castle called Buckingham Palace. I got to see the outside there, but my mom showed me some pictures of the inside. I love it there. But the outside doesn't look very fancy to me. But I never knew why those …

    via Anna Wise's Blog Posts April 25, 2022

    What is causality to an evidential decision theorist?

    (Subsumed by: Timeless Decision Theory, EDT=CDT) People sometimes object to evidential decision theory by saying: “It seems like the distinction between correlation and causation is really important to making good decisions in practice. So how can a theor…

    via The sideways view April 17, 2022

    more     (via openring)


  • Posts
  • RSS
  • ◂◂RSS
  • Contact