Dual Bagpipes

September 7th, 2018
bagpipes, ideas, music
A standard bagpipe has a single bag feeding multiple pipes. The player keeps the bag inflated with their mouth, and maintains the bag at a constant pressure with their left arm. The chanter and drones all respond differently to varying amounts of pressure, so that constant pressure is really important.

But what if we added a second bag, under the player's other arm, which powered the drones? Now the player can intentionally modulate the pressure on the drone bag to make the drones vary rhythmically:

Alternatively, instead of chaining the bags you could pipe the player's air into both of them directly, allowing them to vary the pressure on the chanter as well. My impression is that this is less useful, because when pipers play with just their chanter I've always seen them keep a steady pressure instead of using variation in pressure to add expression. Or maybe bagpipe culture is just anti-expression, and the instrument is actually quite capable? Or am I paying too much attention to British Isles piping and other traditions do involve varying bag pressure for rhythmic accentuation?

Comment via: google plus, facebook, hacker news, substack

Recent posts on blogs I like:

American effective altruists should probably donate to political candidates

My recommendation for donors who are American citizens or permanent residents is that they donate directly to high-value political candidates.

via Thing of Things December 28, 2025

Opinionated takes on parenting

This post is a collection of parenting takes that sometimes go through my head, based on my experience raising our two boys (5 and 2 years old). All of this is based on my experience and might not apply to others (see the law of equal and opposite advice)…

via Victoria Krakovna December 16, 2025

How to Make a Christmas Wreath

Yesterday, I made a Christmas wreath. Here's how to make one. First, find an evergreen tree near your house. Clip off a few branches from the tree. Try to have as many leaves or needles on the branches as possible. Next, bring them home. What I usu…

via Anna Wise's Blog Posts December 6, 2025

more     (via openring)