::  Posts  ::  RSS  ::  ◂◂RSS  ::  Contact

Dirname is Evil

February 11th, 2016
tech  [html]

I recently was writing some code [1] that needed to know the parent directory of a file:

  size_t final_slash = filename.find_last_of('/');
  return filename.substr(0, final_slash);

Why do this when there's dirname(3)? Because dirname is evil:

  • It has big traps.
  • Different implementations have different traps.

On some systems, dirname modifies its input. For example, here's an implementation that's nearly [2] posix conforming:

  char* dirname(char* path) {
    static char dot[] = ".";
    if (!path) return dot;
    char* last_slash = NULL;
    for (char* p = path; *p; p++) {
      if (*p == '/') last_slash = p;
    }
    if (!last_slash) return dot;
    *last_slash = '\0';
    return path;
  }
There are nice things about this: it doesn't need to allocate any memory and it's thread safe. This is what glibc does and is probably the most common behavior. Still, modifying your input string may not be what you want!

Systems can choose, however, to define it in other ways. For example, here's an implementation that leaves its input alone, but instead isn't thread-safe.

  char* dirname(char* path) {
    static char buffer[PATH_MAX];
    static const char dot[] = ".";
    if (!path) return dot;
    size_t last_slash_pos = -1;
    for (size_t i; path[i]; i++) {
      if (i >= PATH_MAX) return dot
      if (path[i] == '/') last_slash_pos = i;
    }
    if (last_slash_pos == -1) return dot;
    strncpy(buffer, path, last_slash_pos);
    buffer[last_slash_pos] = '\0';
    return buffer;
  }

Instead of modifying its argument, this version of dirname uses internal storage. This means that it's not thread safe, and you can't trust its return value to stick around if you call anything that might possibly also call dirname.

One more thing: dirname returns a char* not a const char* but it's not always safe to modify its return value. For example, glibc does:

  char *dirname (char *path) {
    static const char dot[] = ".";
    ...
    /* This assignment is ill-designed
       but the XPG specs require to
       return a string containing "."
       in any case no directory part is
       found and so a static and constant
       string is required.  */
    path = (char *) dot;
    return path;
  }

This means if you give dirname a slashless string and pass the output to something that modifies its input, you'll pass compile-time const checking but you're in for problems at runtime. [3]

So if you're going to use dirname you have to treat it as being both thread unsafe and input modifying. At which point it's much easier to use something else that's better specified.

(Warning: I haven't actually tried running or even compiling these code samples.)


[1] Update 2016-02-12: that code no longer needs anything like dirname at all because I rewrote it to handle everything with pipes instead of PID files.

[2] I've left out the bit where it's supposed to ignore trailing '/' characters.

[3] Either changing the return value of dirname for future calls, or undefined behavior, I'm not sure which.

Comment via: google plus, facebook

Recent posts on blogs I like:

How Fast New York Regional Rail Could Be Part 2

In my last post about New York regional rail schedules, I covered the New Haven and Harlem Lines of Metro-North and the Main Line and Hempstead Branch of the LIRR. I was hoping to cover more lines tonight, but due to time constraints only the Hudson Line …

via Pedestrian Observations October 17, 2019

Strong stances

I. The question of confidence Should one hold strong opinions? Some say yes. Some say that while it’s hard to tell, it tentatively seems pretty bad (probably). There are many pragmatically great upsides, and a couple of arguably unconscionable downsides. …

via Meteuphoric October 15, 2019

What do executives do, anyway?

An executive with 8,000 indirect reports and 2000 hours of work in a year can afford to spend, at most, 15 minutes per year per person in their reporting hierarchy... even if they work on nothing else. That job seems impossible. How can anyone make any im…

via apenwarr September 29, 2019

more     (via openring)

More Posts:


  ::  Posts  ::  RSS  ::  ◂◂RSS  ::  Contact