Why the SmartGiving Subreddit Isn't Interested in Your Charity

July 13th, 2012
ea
In general, an appeal for your favorite charity is not appropriate on the SmartGiving subreddit. Which may be surprising: your charity is helping people, actually making a difference in peoples lives, and don't these people deserve our help? Why wouldn't we want to hear about it and support it? Aren't we generous people interested in giving opportunities? Yesterday someone posted:
Would you give these kids a second chance?

Charity X is a nonprofit organization that helps home adolescent children from dysfunctional backgrounds and teach them how to interact with the world. These kids are not bad kids, though they have made mistakes. They want and are willing to change. By spreading Charity X's name, you can help give these kids a second chance. Please give them that chance.

The problem is that there are too many people in the world that need help. Even if we work as hard as we can to eradicate malaria and other neglected tropical diseases, some people will still die. Other people will suffer needlessly from intestinal parasites, limiting their cognitive development and causing them pain. There are people receiving vaccines that have lost potency because the distributing organizations don't have the logistical capacity to keep them consistently refrigerated through their entire transportation system. There are effective charities working to fix all three of these [1], and in general there are so many ways to help people that we need to apply a form of triage: where can our money do the most good?

This means asking ourselves not just "is this organization doing something valuable?" (yes!) or "do these people deserve help?" (of course!) but "is this organization better than all the competing ones?" That's a very high standard. If you found your favorite charity by personal appeal, friendship with people working there, being personally helped, or anything other than a thorough search for the best one, it's very unlikely to meet it.

[1] The Against Malaria Foundation, the Schistosomiasis Control Initiative, and Village Reach. Links are to their GiveWell reviews.

Comment via: google plus, facebook, r/smartgiving, substack

Recent posts on blogs I like:

“We should be more ambitious with the software we build”

Since early this year, Michael Malis (of pgrust) has been showing me interesting things he's done and saying [W]e should be more ambitious1 with the software we build There is, understandably, a lot of skepticism about projects like pgrust because there…

via Posts on October 24, 2026

The DBT guide to intense negative emotions

This is a guide for handling intense negative emotions, based on dialectical behavior therapy.

via Thing of Things October 23, 2026

Was the HuggingFace hacking incident scheming?

In July 2026, internal OpenAI agents hacked HuggingFace (HF) in order to figure out how their evaluation grader works. This involved a thousand agents coordinating on an improvised message board to carry out an elaborate sequence of exploits. A later grou…

via Victoria Krakovna October 18, 2026

more     (via openring)