Region Selection in Italian Power Grid

December 24th, 2016
games
On the France/Italy Power Grid expansion there are the usual six regions, but because of the way Italy is a peninsula there are fewer combinations than usual:

The board has six regions, Brown, Purple, Red, Yellow, Blue, and Green, and in an N player game you randomly choose N connected regions to play with. In a three player game, for example, the options are:

  • Brown, Purple, Red
  • Purple, Red, Yellow
  • Red, Yellow, Blue
  • Red, Yellow, Green
  • Yellow, Blue, Green

When selecting which regions to use, though, what does "randomly" mean? Here are three ways you might consider:

  • Choose three regions at random. If they're not connected, try again.

  • Choose a region at random. Then from the remaining contiguous regions, choose another region at random. Repeat for the third region.

  • Choose one of the five legal combinations at random.

While the first and third options give the same distribution—each of the five options 20% of the time—the second option does not:

30% Brown, Purple, Red
17% Purple, Red, Yellow
16% Red, Yellow, Blue
16% Red, Yellow, Green
21% Yellow, Blue, Green

I think for this game "combinations" is the right thing to be selecting over, so would choose the third selection method above. But if you care more about regions than combinations, you might prefer the second method: with the even-20% method we have Yellow 80% of the time, while in the sequential method we only have it 70% of the time:

Region Even-20% Sequential
Brown 20% 30%
Purple 40% 47%
Red 80% 79%
Yellow 80% 70%
Blue 40% 37%
Green 40% 37%

If an even distribution over regions is our goal, however, intentionally optimizing for it can do better:

Region Even-20% Sequential Region-optimized
Brown 20% 30% 50%
Purple 40% 47% 50%
Red 80% 79% 50%
Yellow 80% 70% 50%
Blue 40% 37% 50%
Green 40% 37% 50%

What does this solution look like?

50% Brown, Purple, Red
0% Purple, Red, Yellow
0% Red, Yellow, Blue
0% Red, Yellow, Green
50% Yellow, Blue, Green

Which shows, I think, that uniformly selecting over combinations of regions is what we want.

Comment via: google plus, facebook

Recent posts on blogs I like:

Effective Altruism: Importance, Tractability, Neglectedness

One of the most distinctive features of effective altruism is the use of the importance, tractability, and neglectedness framework for evaluating charities.

via Thing of Things April 23, 2025

Impact, agency, and taste

understand + work backwards from the root goal • don’t rely too much on permission or encouragement • make success inevitable • find your angle • think real hard • reflect on your thinking

via benkuhn.net April 19, 2025

Which Came First, the Chicken or the Egg?

When I thought about this question it was really hard to figure out because the way it's phrased it's essentially either a chicken just pops into existence, or an egg just pops into existence, without any parent animals involved. I thought about t…

via Lily Wise's Blog Posts April 13, 2025

more     (via openring)