Prototyping in C

September 4th, 2022
Lately I've been writing some new ("greenfield") code in C. I feel a bit silly about this: isn't Rust what you're supposed to use if you want metal-level performance and are unconstrained by past engineering decisions? Or Go? Something on the JVM? Even C++? Why use a 50 year-old language that is notorious for memory unsafety and nasal demons?

There are a few things about this situation that are a pretty good fit for C:

  • I'm prototyping in a data-heavy situation, iterating on the right way to solve various problems. Normally I would use Python for prototyping, and I am using it a bunch here. In many cases, however, I need to run my code quickly over a large amount of data and see how it works in practice, and my Python implementations have generally been far too slow.

  • I'm implementing algorithms that are computationally straight-forward: a Trie to count unique fixed-length substrings (code), or approximating the previous algorithm with multiple processes writing to a big block of shared memory and accepting collisions (code). If I needed library support or had a large amount of tricky logic I'd use a different tool.

  • I'm processing very simple formats: essentially just long strings of [ACGT]*. This keeps the code rule of two compliant. I wouldn't want to use C for any tricky parsing unless it was sandboxed and I was very confident in the sandboxing setup.

  • I'm working on this set of problems mostly by myself, so I should choose the tooling where I'll be able to make progress most quickly. It doesn't matter much right now if my code is a bit weird. Once I get a better handle on how we're going to approach this problem computationally it will likely make sense to rewrite in a modern language, which will both be safer and more readable.

    The biggest risk here is that prototype code will become production code, there will always be something more urgent than a rewrite, and at the core of our system we have a chunk of code in an unsafe language that's poorly documented and confusing to read. This is probably the strongest argument against starting anything in C, even for prototyping. While I can't completely commit to ensuring this doesn't happen, I'm going into this with my eyes open. And I will at least commit to seriously documenting anything that's becoming production code.

This is a bit of an unusual confluence of factors, and if you'd asked me a few years ago if I was ever going to write C professionally again, let alone choose to start something in C, I would have said no. Yet, in this case, I think it's the right call.

(Large parts of my rhythm stage setup, including both the MIDI routing and whistle-controlled synthesizer are also in C, though there for minimizing latency instead of maximizing throughput. Since that's something silly I'm doing for fun I feel less weird about it.)

Comment via: facebook, lesswrong

Recent posts on blogs I like:

Abigail Shrier's Bad Therapy: Surveys

Surveys matter!

via Thing of Things April 12, 2024

Clarendon Postmortem

I posted a postmortem of a community I worked to help build, Clarendon, in Cambridge MA, over at Supernuclear.

via Home March 19, 2024

How web bloat impacts users with slow devices

In 2017, we looked at how web bloat affects users with slow connections. Even in the U.S., many users didn't have broadband speeds, making much of the web difficult to use. It's still the case that many users don't have broadband speeds, both …

via Posts on March 16, 2024

more     (via openring)