Parsing HTML With Regular Expressions

February 22nd, 2013
html, tech
Perhaps you need to get some information out of HTML. Regular expressions look promising, but you get stuck so you ask for help. A typical response would be:
HTML parsing is not possible with regular expressions, since it depends on matching the opening and the closing tag. Regular expressions can only match regular languages but HTML is a context-free language.
This is true, but only in a sense so narrow it's useless. When someone asks about "regular expressions" they don't mean the restricted computer science kind but the implementations available in various programming languages. Those are much more powerful, capable of parsing HTML.

Here again we're using dangerously precise words. When someone says "HTML" they don't mean HTML as defined by the spec but HTML that they are likely to encounter in the real world. Which means you might need to handle monstrosities like "<i>italic <b>bold-italic</i> bold</b>" which have no parse tree but your browser still renders as italic bold-italic bold. [1]

But again with the precision! For typical tasks you don't need to 'parse' HTML, just extract some information from it. Regular expressions and other ad-hoc techniques can do that well and are likely to be less trouble in practice [2] than trying to use a parser.

(Because mod_pagespeed needs to make context-dependent changes to arbitrary web pages, regular expressions are not a good fit. You might think using the parsing code from a web browser would work well, but it turns out that browsers mix HTML-parsing with HTML-cleanup [1]. So pagespeed instead goes token-by-token, triggering callbacks for start and end tags.)


[1] Webkit turns <i>italic <b>bold-italic</i> bold</b> into <i>italic <b>bold-italic</b></i> <b>bold<b> at an early stage of interpreting the page.

[2] The advice to use an XML parser is just bad, as funny as the author is. XML parsers get to assume they're only going to be given valid XML and just reject anything that isn't. Extremely few pages are (or even try to be) XML, so your XML parser isn't going to be helpful.

Comment via: google plus, facebook, hacker news

Recent posts on blogs I like:

On Polarization

weirdmaxxing as a dating strategy

via Thing of Things March 14, 2025

Frozen meals are actually great

I cook most of my meals and am pretty frugal. I do a lot of meal prep (cooking in bulk), so I don’t have to cook every day in order to have food. But sometimes I run out of my meal prep or just want something different, and don’t have energy to cook somet…

via Home March 7, 2025

Breakfast Over February Break

Over February break I made breakfast for me and Nora three days in a row. Normally, my dad makes me, Nora, and Lily breakfast, but my dad and Lily were on a trip and my mom wasn't up yet so I was basically the only one in the house who was awake and cou…

via Anna Wise's Blog Posts March 1, 2025

more     (via openring)