• Posts
  • RSS
  • ◂◂RSS
  • Contact

  • Increasingly OK with Singular They

    June 14th, 2018
    they  [html]
    Six years ago, in 2012, I wrote a post where I made a continuum of examples of singular 'they' usage. Selections:
    • unspecific ungendered: Someone has their head screwed on wrong.
    • specific ungendered: I bet the cop who pulled you over was just trying to meet their quota.
    • specific known-gender ungendered: The person who gave me a ride home from the dance last night doesn't take care of their car.
    • unspecific gendered: Whenever I meet a cute boy contra dancing I friend them on Facebook.
    • specific gendered: Look at that careless woman spilling beer all over their kid!
    At the time I made the list I wrote:
    I'm mostly fine up until the "unspecific gendered" referent, though the previous category can be a little iffy.
    Since then I've looked back at the list every few years, and it's been a helpful way to track how my sense of 'they' has changed. In 2014 I wrote that some of the "unspecific ungendered" category sounded fine to me, and yesterday I noticed I was fine with the whole list.

    Some things that I think have increased by comfort with singular 'they':

    • When writing documentation, I've been using it consistently to refer to people, since they could turn out to have any gender. This is the top of the continuum.

    • When writing interview feedback I use 'they' for the candidate, because I want to help hiring committee focus on the work the candidate showed me. This is the "specific known-gender ungendered" category, in the middle.

    • I have an increasing number of friends who use 'they' pronouns.

    Leah brought up that singular 'they' is generally more accepted for distal referents, something I wasn't thinking about when I wrote my 2012 post. That is, the farther away someone is, in time, space, relevance, etc, the more ok singular 'they' is. Here's another continuum of examples, all specific referents where gender is known to the speaker but not the listener:

    • I got a call from my boss, and it sounded like they were calling through a tin-can telephone.
    • When my boss gets in I can let them know.
    • My boss is over there, with their shoes off.
    • My boss is right here if you want to ask them yourself.
    • This is my boss; they're also a contra dancer.
    To me, the first two sound fine, the middle one I'm not sure about and might depend on distance, and the last two sound like I'm trying to indicate that my boss uses 'they' pronouns.

    One example of this was a friend recently saying:

    Emily [1] can bring the tablecloths when they come.
    This is fine to me in a way that "This is Emily; they brought the tablecloths" would not be. [2] Emily isn't currently present, and they're peripheral to the current discussio.nno

    Overall it seems to me like singular 'they' is continuing to expand in usage. I continue to think a good end state would be one where using it all the time for everyone is the normal thing, and you no longer need to guess people's genders from their appearance and presentation in order to refer to them.

    (At some point I think I'll start pushing "they all" for plural 'they', but not yet. Ideally we can start adding 'all' as needed to disambiguate.)


    [1] Not actually their name.

    [2] Unless Emily used 'they' pronouns, of course.

    Comment via: google plus, facebook

    Recent posts on blogs I like:

    Collections: Iron, How Did They Make It? Part I, Mining

    This week we are starting a four-part look at pre-modern iron and steel production. As with our series on farming, we are going to follow the train of iron production from the mine to a finished object, be that a tool, a piece of armor, a simple nail, a w…

    via A Collection of Unmitigated Pedantry September 18, 2020

    Learning Game

    I came up with this game. In the game one person thinks of something and then gives the other person a clue. And the other person writes a guess down on a blackboard or a piece of paper. Or really anything you have that's laying around that's av…

    via Lily Wise's Blog Posts September 17, 2020

    Hong Kong Construction Costs

    I think we have found the #2 city in urban rail construction costs, behind only New York. This is Hong Kong, setting a world record for the most expensive urban el and encroaching on Singapore for most expensive non-New York subway. As we look for more da…

    via Pedestrian Observations September 16, 2020

    more     (via openring)


  • Posts
  • RSS
  • ◂◂RSS
  • Contact