Crooked Tunes for Ordinary Dances

October 26th, 2010
calling, contra
Contra dance has a very standard musical form: 64 beats in eight 8-beat phrases. Dances require this, though some only need 16-beat phrases and some work better if there's some 4-beat chunkiness. There are a small number of contra dances that don't fit this pattern [1] but I can only think of one [2] that's actually crooked [3]. Dancers certainly notice, which is not ideal as I don't want to make dancers think, but as long as the caller's on top of things it works. Playing around with "the walloping window blind" as a possible dance tune has me thinking how maybe if you could add some beats early in a phrase but still end it clearly, you might be able to keep people from having to think about it at all. The problem with the song in question is that (if A is the verse and B is the chorus) in the middle of the A2 and at the end of the B1 it adds two beats. [4] You can square it up simply by squishing the four rising notes into two beats instead of four, but I'm thinking you might only need to do that with the B part (where it's at the end) if you used the appropriate dance. Anything with a balance and swing in the A2, such as mary cay's, alligator reel, or heartbeat contra, ought to work.

Now I need to try this out with some dancers. I think it would work, but you can't tell until you try it. I also think there's some chance you could actually leave in both places where it's crooked, but I'm not sure.


[1] For example, the chestnut "money musk" which is only 48 beats or the modern dance "alternating corners" which takes 128.

[2] Cherokee Shuffle, when danced with the extra balance at the end gets another four beats of melody.

[3] A crooked tune is one that doesn't divide evenly into eight beat phrases.

[4] If you're looking at the lyrics the beats are added where the words are stretched out: "play-ai-ey-a", "crew-ai-ew-a".

Comment via: substack

Recent posts on blogs I like:

I did a meditation and it sort of changed my personality?!

a trip report

via benkuhn.net November 8, 2026

The bad part about rape is all the rape

I have recently seen a lot of people casually refer to consensual non-consent orgies as “rape orgies”.

via Thing of Things November 6, 2026

Test and verification technique effectiveness with Astra

When we looked at how well agents used test/verification techniques in August1, we saw that GPT-5.6 Sol generally did what you might call a caricature of various techniques when asked to use a technique or library such as TDD, QuickCheck, Lean 4, etc.; no…

via Posts on November 2, 2026

more     (via openring)