::  Posts  ::  RSS  ::  ◂◂RSS  ::  Contact

Against Legal Harmonization

October 26th, 2013
experiments  [html]

We don't know what laws work best. While we all agree that murder should be illegal, should drugs be? Sampling music? Insider trading? Libel? Private property? Abortion? Strong cryptography? To make things more complicated, for most things you might want to make laws about there are lots of different ways to set up the law. For example, you could prohibit chewing gum by via focusing on buyers, sellers, importers, or public consumption. US doctors have to go through four years of college, four years of medical school, three years of residency, and various examinations, but that's clearly not the only way to keep unqualified people from practicing medicine.

Because we have hundreds of countries with their own laws and legal systems, we're constantly exploring this space of ways to run a country. While we're mostly optimizing for welfare and not a thorough search of the space we still end up with lots of policy variance. This means that when we're trying to decide whether to decriminalize drugs we can look at Portugal's experience. In considering euthanasia policy we can see how it's gone in the Netherlands. This is really valuable, and we should do more of it. [1]

Unfortunately the international trend is in the other direction: harmonize the laws. The idea is that there are large costs to having different legal and regulatory setups in different countries so we can reduce those costs by making them more similar. This is a major goal of the EU [2], but also of many international treaties and conventions. The problem is that in many cases the economic benefits of experimentation are likely much larger than the reductions in costs provided by more similar systems. How long should copyright be for the best economic effect? With the progressive strengthening of the Berne Convention we've stopped collecting data.

Some amount of harmonization is definitely valuable. For example the 2005 Convention on the Use of Electronic Communications in International Contracts probably did a lot to reduce trade costs without cutting off exploration early. The problem is that the value of experimentation and the possibility that we might not know which laws are best until we try them seems to be entirely left out of the conversation.


[1] There are some areas of policy that are hard to explore because of freedom of migration. For example, countries can invest in their citizens in various ways, such as through education, and then recoup the money through lower salaries or higher taxes. If this ends up with some citizens acquiring especially valuable skills, such as medical training, then as adults they may leave the country for others with more privatized systems where they can earn much more. This was a particular concern of Eastern Bloc countries, who responded by prohibiting emigration. I doubt the knowledge gained from experimentation is anywhere near enough to make up for the level of oppression that keeping people from leaving allows.

[2] And while not separate countries, we see the same dynamic and effects at the state level in the US.

Comment via: google plus, facebook

Recent posts on blogs I like:

How Fast New York Regional Rail Could Be Part 2

In my last post about New York regional rail schedules, I covered the New Haven and Harlem Lines of Metro-North and the Main Line and Hempstead Branch of the LIRR. I was hoping to cover more lines tonight, but due to time constraints only the Hudson Line …

via Pedestrian Observations October 17, 2019

Strong stances

I. The question of confidence Should one hold strong opinions? Some say yes. Some say that while it’s hard to tell, it tentatively seems pretty bad (probably). There are many pragmatically great upsides, and a couple of arguably unconscionable downsides. …

via Meteuphoric October 15, 2019

What do executives do, anyway?

An executive with 8,000 indirect reports and 2000 hours of work in a year can afford to spend, at most, 15 minutes per year per person in their reporting hierarchy... even if they work on nothing else. That job seems impossible. How can anyone make any im…

via apenwarr September 29, 2019

more     (via openring)

More Posts:


  ::  Posts  ::  RSS  ::  ◂◂RSS  ::  Contact