Salary Advisor

November 30th, 2012
money
We bargain over a very small number of things in the US, which means we're not very good at it. With a job offer there's generally room to negotiate, often quite a lot. Depending on which field you're in it might be 5%-50%? While hiring someone to negotiate on your behalf would send weird signals to your prospective employer, hiring someone for advice is much more subtle. They could have a good idea of how much you might be able to get here [1] and what you could get elsewhere. They could review offer letters, suggest counter-offers, maybe even provide some training in verbal negotiation.

(In some fields it's common to have strict pay grades with clearly defined criteria while in others it's much more flexible. A salary advisor would probably be field-specific, and it would make sense for them to pick a field where amounts are on the variable end.)

Incentives are most aligned if they're paid a fraction of the additional compensation they help you negotiate. Which isn't possible, but an agreement up-front like "X% of every dollar over $Y", where $Y is a number you think is what you could get on your own, might be good.

(I don't see anything like this out there, but it's hard to say for sure because the search results are so full of scummy seo minimal-content lots-of-job-ads results. You can do this somewhat self-service with places like glassdoor and there are compensation specialists, doing this work on the other side in HR, but the potential compensation range in some fields is large enough that it would probably be worth hiring an expert.)

Update 2017-05-18: Someone made something like this.


[1] Maybe it would make sense for them to offer to pay small amounts for salary details, bonus amounts, etc. And they could collect current ones from anyone asking for advice.

Referenced in: Markov Me

Comment via: google plus, facebook, substack

Recent posts on blogs I like:

Ozy at LessOnline!

I will once again be a guest at LessOnline, alongside many other writers whom you no doubt like less than you like me: Scott Alexander, dynomight, Georgia Ray, David Friedman, Nicholas Decker, Jacob Falkovich, Kelsey Piper, Alicorn, Aella, etc.

via Thing of Things March 23, 2026

Daycares and the Brown School

As someone in Somerville I notice that there are quite high prices regarding childcare. The average family in Somerville pays $1,100 to $3,500 for daycare per month, and I want to make the costs more affordable. I have also noticed that housing is quite …

via Lily Wise's Blog Posts March 22, 2026

2025-26 New Year review

This is an annual post reviewing the last year and setting intentions for next year. I look over different life areas (work, health, parenting, effectiveness, etc) and analyze my life tracking data. Highlights include a minimal group house, the usefulness…

via Victoria Krakovna January 19, 2026

more     (via openring)