Require Keyword Arguments

July 13th, 2014
python, tech
To avoid errors in calling a python function you might want to ensure it's only ever called with keyword arguments. Say you have:
    def score(actual, predicted):
       ...
and you're worried people accidentally call it with the arguments reversed. After all, nothing looks surprising with:
    score(model.predict(data), isRepaid)
We can have a culture where everyone writes in the keyword arguments, as:
    score(actual=isRepaid, predicted=model.predict(data))
This mostly solves the problem, but could we have Python check this for us? Yes! PEP 3102 added this to Python 3+:
    def score(*, actual, predicted):
      ..
But what about the Python 2 series? You could rebuild Python with this patch applied, or you could use a decorator that verifies there are no positional arguments and then calls the original function:
    def poscheck(f):
      def checked_f(*args, **kwargs):
        if args:
          raise PositionalArgumentsError(f)
        f(**kwargs)
      return checked_f

    @poscheck
    def score(actual, predicted):
      ...
This is pretty good, but what about a case like this:
    # Split s on newlines ('\n'), returning a list.  These newlines
    # are not normally retained, but if the optional keepends argument
    # is True then they're kept.
    def splitlines(s, keepends=False):
       ...
If someone calls splitlines as splitlines(s, True) that's going to be pretty confusing to a reader. You'd like to make sure writers always make it clear what the boolean is about, so you have a house style where you write splitlines(s, keepends=True). If you used poscheck, though, that would require splitlines(s=s, keepends=True) which is too verbose. So, use poscheck_except instead:
    @poscheck_except(1)
    def splitlines(s, keepends=False):
      ...
This will require that after the first positional argument all other arguments are given with keywords, if present.

The code is poscheck on github.

Comment via: google plus, facebook, substack

Recent posts on blogs I like:

Microfictions 2

A few more microfictions, still no LLMs.

via Evan Fields August 7, 2026

Linkpost for August

Announcement: for the next while, I’ll be writing the Effective Altruism Newsletter!

via Thing of Things August 6, 2026

Using AI to analyze life patterns

If you’re anything like me, you may have a lot of notes from various introspective activities – annual / monthly reviews, worksheets, therapy notes, etc. Often these notes are just gathering dust in a paper folder or some forgotten corner of Google Drive.…

via Victoria Krakovna July 30, 2026

more     (via openring)