Mask and Respirator Intelligibility Comparison

December 6th, 2024
bio, covid-19, masks, tech
One of the downsides of wearing a mask or respirator is that it makes it hard for people to understand you. That there's stuff getting in the way of free air movement is kind of the point, but ideally it would be possible to let vibration through without net air movement. I recently saw that 3M had updated their respirator line to include an option for a speaking diaphragm, and wanted to test it out.

I compared four options:

I recorded myself on my MacBook with Audacity, reading the same paragraph in with each setup:

(wav).

(wav).

(wav).

(wav).

To me, the no-mask version is by far the clearest, but if I only heard the N95 version I probably wouldn't notice that anything was off. The two reusable respirators are the least intelligible by a good bit, and the speaking diaphragm helps a lot less than I'd hoped.

Here's a frequency plot (script, script):

Unfortunately, since I don't have a great sense of how important each frequency range is for understanding speech, I don't find this all that helpful. But maybe you do?

(One thing I do really like about the new version of 3M's reusable respirator, though, is the button for fit testing. You press the button and it closes off the filters, and if you're able to breath in then the mask is not sealed.)

Referenced in: Mini PAPR Review

Comment via: facebook, lesswrong, mastodon, bluesky

Recent posts on blogs I like:

Book Review: The Kingdom, The Power, and the Glory

Against the Internet

via Thing of Things April 25, 2025

Impact, agency, and taste

understand + work backwards from the root goal • don’t rely too much on permission or encouragement • make success inevitable • find your angle • think real hard • reflect on your thinking

via benkuhn.net April 19, 2025

Which Came First, the Chicken or the Egg?

When I thought about this question it was really hard to figure out because the way it's phrased it's essentially either a chicken just pops into existence, or an egg just pops into existence, without any parent animals involved. I thought about t…

via Lily Wise's Blog Posts April 13, 2025

more     (via openring)