::  Posts  ::  RSS  ::  ◂◂RSS  ::  Contact

Double Tongue Whistling

October 2nd, 2019
ling, whistling  [html]
I can whistle about seven notes per second, which corresponds to a reel at 105bpm. [1] While this isn't a problem for whistling basslines it's slightly too slow for melodies at contra dance speed (~110-122bpm). I want to figure out how to whistle faster, and I know there are people who whistle faster, but I don't know how it's usually done.

I see two main routes:

  • Do what I currently do, but faster.

  • Figure out how to do something else.

The former doesn't seem very promising: I've been playing around with whistling for decades and I suspect I'm pretty close to a local maximum with my current approach. On the other hand, I'm just trying to get from seven notes per second to eight, which seems like it might be possible?

The latter is pretty open, and probably involves doing something that's slower at first but will eventually be faster. The main problem is, how do I know that after I put in all that effort I'll actually end up with something faster? Ideally there would be people demonstrating on youtube or something, with "here's how to whistle quickly" videos, but I'm not seeing that.

Still, it seems like some sort of double-tonguing should work. Normally when I whistle I mark the notes with my glottis, the same as the two glottal stops in "uh-oh". A different option, though, would be to mark the notes by making a velar closure with my tongue, the same as the two velar stops in "cook" ("k"). And then I could alternate between them, which seems like it should let me get up to twice the speed of the slower one. Here's what the three sound like:

I find velar stops harder, partly because it's not what I'm used to, and partly because I'm already using my tongue to form the whistle. Currently I can them 4-5 times per second. When alternating I can do a little better, 5-6 times per second, but that's still less than the 8-10 you'd expect from doubling my velar-only speed. I can go te-ke-te-ke with closures 10-11 times per second, so I am optimistic.

Has anyone learned to double-tongue their whistling successfully? Does this work?


[1] Or a jig at 140bpm, since that's six notes per measure instead of eight.

Comment via: facebook, lesswrong

Recent posts on blogs I like:

Transfers from Infrequent to Frequent Vehicles

Imagine yourself taking a train somewhere, and imagine the train is big and infrequent. Let’s say it’s the commuter train from New York down the Northeast Corridor to Newark Airport, or perhaps a low-cost OuiGo TGV from Lyon to Paris. Now imagine that you…

via Pedestrian Observations January 20, 2020

Veganism and restrictive eating

I’m reading the book Intuitive Eating, which I highly recommend. I was looking for something like it that could get me back to trusting my biological hunger without worrying that I need to control myself or my weight. It’s raised my consciousness to the w…

via Holly Elmore January 17, 2020

Algorithms interviews: theory vs. practice

When I ask people at trendy big tech companies why algorithms quizzes are mandatory, the most common answer I get is something like "we have so much scale, we can't afford to have someone accidentally write an O(n^2) algorithm and bring the site d…

via Posts on Dan Luu January 5, 2020

more     (via openring)

More Posts:


  ::  Posts  ::  RSS  ::  ◂◂RSS  ::  Contact