Do Charlie Cards save money?

May 5th, 2012
mbta, transit
MBTA bus fare with a Charlie Card is $1.25 but it's $1.50 with a 'Charlie Ticket' (or cash). So you'd think you do better to use a Charlie Card. The readers for the tickets are much less robust, however, and are often broken. When they are, the driver waves you on. Even when they're working, drivers often wave on ticket-holders when there's a big line because the readers are so slow and they don't want to be late. I haven't kept track, but this might well be more than one out of every six trips. In which case you save money with the tickets.

(You would do even better to usually use a card but pull out the ticket when you see a big line or a broken reader. This seems kind of sneaky, though.)

This doesn't work for the subway because there are multiple turnstyles and they aren't ever all not taking tickets at once. It does work for the commuter rail in a different way, in that on some lines the conductor doesn't always make it all the way through the train each time and so you might do better with a 12-ride ticket than a monthly pass. Especially if you pay attention to the routine and choose where to sit based on their coverage. But again, that seems sneaky.

Comment via: google plus, facebook, substack

Recent posts on blogs I like:

The odds are good and the goods are great

I stole the title and thesis of this post from the great etirabys and arguably I should just link her post.

via Thing of Things August 31, 2026

Bug blindness

I used to wonder why I see so many more bugs than most people. I easily observe hundreds to thousands of bugs per week and nothing seems to work, but most people I talk to don't see anything like this. For a long time, I thought this had something to …

via Posts on August 30, 2026

Microfictions 2

A few more microfictions, still no LLMs.

via Evan Fields August 7, 2026

more     (via openring)