|November 22nd, 2014|
People really hate it when web servers decide what to do based on User-Agent:
"UA strings need to die a horrible horrible death."
"The UA string is flawed by itself. it shouldn't even be used anymore. The fact that browser manufacturers have to include all sorts of stuff is proof that this system doesn't work."
"Well written sites use feature detection, not user-agent detection."
"We'd all be better off if they just stopped sending the UA string altogether"
Let's say I want to show you a picture of a kitten:
How big is that?  It depends how we encode it:
|Unoptimized JPEG||290.0 kB|
|Optimized JPEG||38.6 kB|
|Optimized WebP||20.2 kB|
To emit html that references either a JPEG or a WebP depending on the browser, you need some way that the server can tell whether the browser supports WebP. Because this feature is so valuable, there is a standard way of indicating support for it: include image/webp in the Accept header. Unfortunately this doesn't quite work in practice. For example, Chrome v36 on iOS broke support for WebP images outside of data:// urls but was still sending Accept: image/webp. Similarly, Opera added image/webp to their Accept header before they supported WebP lossless. And no one indicates in their Accept whether they support animated WebP.
This leaves us having to look at the User-Agent header to figure out what the browser is, and then look up what features that browser supports. The header is ugly, I hate having to do this, but if we want to make pages fast we need to use the UA.
(The full gory details: kernel/http/user_agent_matcher.cc.)
 I uploaded this picture to my server as a poorly optimized jpeg, but I'm running PageSpeed. You should be seeing WebP if your browser supports it, or an optimized JPEG if it doesn't.
 Which would be a bit of an awkward function.
 This only is a problem because of the external script reference. If there were nothing to block the regular parser then both versions would be just as good. (1, 2) Most pages do reference external scripts, however, so in practice the preload scanner helps a lot and you don't want to disable it.
- Rationing With Small Reserves
- Singular They FAQ
- Charities and Waste
- Objecting to Situations
- Mandolin Microphone Placement