Quotation Detection

July 20th, 2012
algorithms, tech
I want to thread comments: when a comment quotes another comment it's probably a reply, so attach them together to make the conversation clearer. This means figuring out which comments quote which other comments. I tried a brute force way:
  for each comment A:
    for each later comment B:
      for each word X in A:
        for each word Y in B:
          do A and B match for N words starting at X and Y?
This is psuedocode for an O(n^2*m^2) solution. Not so good. I coded it up in javascript and while I think it's fast enough in Chrome, Firefox, and even my phone, it took IE8 nearly a minute. While I could probably run this on my server and do fine with some combination of caching and C, it seems inefficient. Is there a better algorithm? What is the general version of this problem called?

Update 2012-07-21: Several commenters suggested a better algorithm: to find all quotes of length N, build a dictionary from all sequences of N words to a list of comments in which they appeared. This is O(n*m) and running it it's much faster. I tested it in IE8, and it loaded quickly instead of freezing the browser. I thought briefly about doing something like this earlier, but wrote it off as using insane amounts of memory. After more people suggested it, I realized it only uses N times as much memory as just storing the comments.

Comment via: google plus, facebook, substack

Recent posts on blogs I like:

Coping with shame

[Mod note: comments on this post about how I’m a good person who should feel better about myself will be deleted.

via Thing of Things August 4, 2026

Using AI to analyze life patterns

If you’re anything like me, you may have a lot of notes from various introspective activities – annual / monthly reviews, worksheets, therapy notes, etc. Often these notes are just gathering dust in a paper folder or some forgotten corner of Google Drive.…

via Victoria Krakovna July 30, 2026

Exercises in benchmarking and evals, part 7: DeepSWE, Senior SWE-Bench, napkin math, and winter tires

This is part of a series of exercises on benchmarking, evals, and experimental design (1, 2, 3, 4, 5, 6)1. We're going to look at three questions, which are presented before the answers to give you time to think about the questions before seeing the a…

via Posts on July 23, 2026

more     (via openring)